Institution news

From Submission to Success: Key Steps in Research Paper Publication and Peer Review, Pakistan Group

Dr. Aneela Wakeel

From Submission to Success: Key Steps in Research Paper Publication and Peer Review, Pakistan Group
From Submission to Success: Key Steps in Research Paper Publication and Peer Review, Pakistan Group

On 5 August 2024, the IMechE University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Taxila Student Chapter organised an insightful seminar titled "From Submission to Success: Key Steps in Research Paper Publication and Peer Review."

Led by Dr. Muhammad Zubair from the Department of Mechanical & Nuclear Engineering, University of Sharjah, UAE, the seminar aimed to equip engineering students with essential knowledge on publishing their research in prestigious journals and navigating the peer review process. The event emphasised the importance of research publication for academic and professional growth, offering practical guidance on each step from manuscript preparation to responding to reviewer feedback.

Importance of Research Publication

Dr. Zubair opened the seminar by discussing the historical significance of research publication, tracing its roots back to 1665 with the founding of the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society. He highlighted the critical role of publications in the dissemination of knowledge, fostering collaboration, and enhancing researchers' profiles. He emphasised that for scientists and engineers, publishing is not just about career advancement but also about contributing to the collective understanding of their field.

Choosing the Right Journal

The seminar provided an overview of how to select the appropriate journal for publication. With over 300,000 journals globally, of which around 101,000 are active scholarly titles, students were guided on using resources like Scopus and the Elsevier Journal Finder to identify the best-suited journals based on impact factor, scope, and target readership. Dr. Zubair also explained the importance of understanding journal rankings and metrics to prioritise reading and submission efforts.

Preparing the Manuscript

A detailed breakdown of the manuscript preparation process was shared, focusing on three key stages:

  • Topic Selection: Identifying a relevant and impactful research topic.
  • Data Collection and Analysis: Gathering credible and reliable data.
  • Writing the Manuscript: Structuring the paper with a clear abstract, introduction, methodology, results, discussion, and conclusion. The importance of adhering to ethical standards and ensuring compliance with journal guidelines was underscored.

The Submission and Peer Review Process

The submission process was highlighted as a critical step, with guidance on selecting the right journal, understanding submission guidelines, and using online submission platforms like Scholar One or Editorial Manager. Dr. Zubair explained the different types of peer review—single-blind, double-blind, and open review—and their impact on the publication process. He emphasised that interpreting reviewer feedback and revising the manuscript accordingly is as crucial as the original research itself.

Ethical Standards in Publication

The seminar concluded with a discussion on maintaining high ethical standards in research and publication. Dr. Zubair addressed common unethical practices such as plagiarism, the use of AI tools for writing, ghost authorship, and data fabrication. He stressed the importance of integrity and diligence in research, encouraging participants to prioritise quality over quantity in their publication efforts.

Relevance to IMechE and the Global Engineering Community

This seminar is of particular interest to the IMechE community as it aligns with the organisation's commitment to advancing engineering knowledge and supporting the professional development of engineers worldwide. By equipping young engineers with the skills needed to successfully publish their research, the event contributes to the global exchange of innovative ideas and the continuous improvement of engineering practices.

Conclusion

The "From Submission to Success" seminar provided invaluable insights into the research publication process, empowering engineering students to navigate the complexities of academic publishing with confidence. The event not only highlighted the technical aspects of writing and submitting research papers but also reinforced the ethical considerations essential to maintaining the integrity of the scientific community.

Share:

Professional Engineering magazine

Professional Engineering app

  • Industry features and content
  • Engineering and Institution news
  • News and features exclusive to app users

Download our Professional Engineering app

Professional Engineering newsletter

A weekly round-up of the most popular and topical stories featured on our website, so you won't miss anything

Subscribe to Professional Engineering newsletter

Opt into your industry sector newsletter

Related articles